Manila, Philippines – Negotiations between China and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) to establish a code of conduct for the South China Sea have stalled, failing to reach a conclusion during recent meetings in Manila. Despite tentative agreement on approximately 80 percent of a draft document, several critical issues remain unresolved, including whether the code will be legally binding, according to the Philippines’ foreign minister.

These protracted discussions are crucial given the overlapping territorial claims in the strategically vital South China Sea, a region where maritime encounters have frequently led to heightened tensions. ASEAN and Beijing have been attempting to forge a code of conduct for over two decades as a framework to manage these disputes and prevent escalation.

The Philippines, currently holding the rotating chairmanship of the 11-nation bloc, had expressed a commitment to accelerating the process with the goal of finalizing a deal by the end of the current year. However, Foreign Minister Theresa Lazaro indicated that differing perspectives between the ASEAN member states and China on various aspects of the proposed code persist, hindering progress.

Southeast Asian nations involved in the negotiations are seeking a code that aligns with international law, a principle they argue China has not consistently upheld. Beijing, on the other hand, maintains that its activities in the region are lawful and professional. The South China Sea is a focal point of competing claims, with China asserting sovereignty over most of it, which encroaches upon the exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam.

An international arbitration tribunal ruled in 2016 that China's extensive claims lacked a legal basis under international law, a decision that Beijing has not recognized. The ongoing maritime confrontations, particularly between China and the Philippines, underscore the urgency for a functional code. Recent incidents include aggressive maneuvers, the use of water cannons by Chinese coastguard vessels, and disruptions to Philippine resupply missions within its own exclusive economic zone.

Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.'s administration has seen an escalation of these tensions since he took office in 2022, marked by sharp exchanges between the two nations concerning maritime activities prior to the recent ASEAN meetings.

Looking ahead, Lazaro conveyed hope that the code might be finalized under Singapore's chairmanship, as the city-state is set to assume the role of ASEAN chair next year. This indicates a continued diplomatic effort, albeit with significant hurdles still to overcome.

In a separate development concerning regional stability, ASEAN leaders also extended a ban preventing Myanmar's leader from attending the bloc's annual summits. This decision was made in response to Myanmar's failure to adhere to a previous agreement reached in 2021 following the military coup.