The author of the independent review into gender identity services for young people, Baroness Cass, has stated she does not support the current draft of the bill intended to ban conversion practices. Previously, she had welcomed the legislation, but her stance has shifted due to concerns about unintended consequences for those involved with children experiencing gender distress.

Conversion practices are broadly defined as attempts to change or suppress an individual's sexual orientation or gender identity, often occurring in familial or religious contexts. Campaigns have long sought to outlaw such practices in the UK, with the Labour party pledging to introduce a ban in their 2024 manifesto.

When the government introduced its draft legislation in June, Baroness Cass was quoted in promotional material, expressing pleasure at the bill's clearer definitions of conversion practices. She had also stated she looked forward to further scrutiny before it became law. However, when questioned by a parliamentary committee, she explicitly stated her current opposition to the bill's form.

Baroness Cass articulated that the polarized debate surrounding gender issues could lead to the law being applied in ways not originally intended. She specifically pointed to the bill's requirement for victims to suffer "serious harm" to their health or "serious alarm or distress" with a "substantial adverse effect" on daily activities.

She expressed worry that this wording could open the door to vexatious complaints, potentially jeopardizing therapists who work with young people experiencing gender distress. Baroness Cass illustrated this by suggesting that discussions about traumatic experiences, such as sexual abuse, which are often necessary in therapy, might inadvertently fall foul of the law if not handled with extreme care.

Professionals at the new NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics have also voiced concerns that even complaint processes not leading to prosecution could be damaging. Baroness Cass highlighted potential impacts on families, noting that parental actions, such as withholding funds if a child intended to purchase a breast binder or hormones, might also be subject to prosecution under the current bill.

Addressing her earlier positive remarks, Baroness Cass clarified that her support was for the principle of banning conversion practices, but she had not had sufficient time to review the specific details of the draft legislation before its initial publication. The government has indicated it welcomes her feedback and will consider all evidence presented by the committee to ensure the ban is implemented correctly.

The bill aims to protect LGBT people in England and Wales, but Baroness Cass's critique raises significant questions about its scope and potential impact on therapeutic work and parental actions related to gender-affirming care.