Alan Milburn's comprehensive plan to address the crisis of young people not in education, employment, or training (Neets) is projected to save the UK welfare system a modest £200 million per year by 2036. While Milburn believes his reforms could cut welfare costs by £13.8 billion over the next decade, this figure is offset by significant proposed government spending on job guarantees, hiring incentives, and support services.

The reforms aim to tackle a growing number of young people claiming benefits, particularly health and disability payments. The report estimates that approximately £8 billion is currently spent annually on benefits for young people, including £4.6 billion on Universal Credit and £3.2 billion on Personal Independence Payments (Pip).

The number of 16-24 year olds claiming the health element of Universal Credit has surged from 105,000 in 2020 to 193,000 this year. Similarly, Pip claimants in this age group have risen from 230,000 to 511,000, with official forecasts predicting this number could exceed 800,000 by 2037.

Milburn's strategy involves a dual approach: increasing government investment in employment and training programs while simultaneously reducing certain welfare payments for this demographic. The plan calls for an additional £5.8 billion in annual spending by 2036 for initiatives like employment subsidies and mental health support.

Key to the proposed savings are changes to the benefits system for under-25s. Milburn suggests a new "Youth Allowance" to replace Universal Credit for this age group and an "Additional Cost Allowance" to potentially substitute Pip benefits. These changes are estimated to reduce total welfare spending by £3.6 billion a year by 2036 compared to current projections.

Milburn has stated his diagnosis of the Neets crisis applies across the UK, but acknowledged that education, skills, health, and local government are devolved matters. He has urged Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland to agree on a common set of objectives for addressing the issue.

Critics have raised concerns about the rising welfare and tax proposals embedded within the reforms. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) data highlights the significant increase in young claimants, underscoring the scale of the challenge.

The long-term fiscal impact of these reforms remains a subject of scrutiny, with the projected net savings of £200 million per year by 2036 appearing less substantial when weighed against the initial investment and the overarching welfare bill, which is forecast to reach £353 billion this year.