Warsaw, Poland – Poland’s main political factions are engaged in a fierce struggle for control over the Constitutional Tribunal, a battle that analysts warn is undermining public trust in the state and playing directly into Russian President Vladimir Putin’s strategic interests.

The dispute, which has roots stretching back over a decade, centers on the appointment and legitimacy of judges to the tribunal. The current confrontation involves the center-right Civic Platform, now in power, attempting to install new judges, while the tribunal’s leadership, aligned with the conservative Law and Justice party, has blocked their entry.

Last month, a newly appointed judge ordered the suspension of the tribunal’s president and deputy, leading to a police deployment at the building. President Andrzej Duda, aligned with Law and Justice, characterized the action as an attempted "forcible takeover," while Prime Minister Donald Tusk, leading the Civic Platform coalition, defended it as a necessary step to "restore the rule of law."

This internal conflict provides fertile ground for external actors. Moscow has already leveraged the situation, with former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev labeling the intervention a "coup." Such narratives cast doubt on the stability and legitimacy of Poland’s democratic institutions, a common tactic in Russian foreign policy to weaken neighboring states.

The current political maneuvering echoes a decade-old controversy. In 2015, the outgoing Civic Platform-led parliament attempted to appoint judges for vacancies that would fall to the subsequent government. The incoming Law and Justice administration then intensified its efforts to appoint party loyalists to the tribunal, bypassing established legal procedures.

Now, the roles appear reversed, with the liberal coalition employing tactics that critics, including some liberal experts, argue disregard legal niceties. The conservative Law and Justice party is rallying its supporters under the banner of defending the rule of law, a slogan previously championed by the liberal opposition when Law and Justice was in power.

Prime Minister Tusk, portrayed by some as a strongman figure, appears to be prioritizing decisive action, even amid legal questions. This situation highlights a concerning trend where major political parties adopt similar, often contentious, approaches to institutional control, blurring lines and eroding public confidence.

The ongoing constitutional battle risks further fracturing public trust and weakening Poland’s democratic resilience, creating an opening for foreign influence and disinformation campaigns aimed at destabilizing the nation.